Correcting Anti-Zionist Metaphor

The Metaphor of the Falling Man -Benny Morris

A metaphor coined in The Atlantic:

A Zionist Jew, to save himself, leaps from a burning building (anti-Semitic and Holocaust Europe) and lands on an innocent bystander (a Palestinian), crushing him.

But the metaphor is disingenuous, and it requires amplification to conform to the facts of history.

In fact, as the leaping man nears the ground he offers the bystander a compromise - let's share the pavement, some for you, some for me. The bystander responds with a firm "no," and tries, again and again (1920, 1921, 1929, the Arab Revolt of 1936-39 and the 1947-48 War of Independence), to stab the falling man as he descends to the pavement.

Later, again and again, the leaping man, now firmly ensconced on the pavement, offers the bystander a compromise ("autonomy" in 1978, a "two-state solution" in 2000 and in 2008), and again and again the bystander says "no."

The falling man may have somewhat wronged the bystander, but the bystander was never an innocent one; he was an active agent in and a party to his own demise.
(Ha'aretz)
*